For the first time in over three months, Coach Paul Johnson has obtained a commitment from a prospect of any note.
Three-star offensive lineman Errin Joe out of Lakeland, FL pledged for Tech on Sunday, toting behind a respectable list of offers which included Miami(FL) and West Virginia. Tech was reportedly Joe's second choice, but the committable offer from his first pick, FSU, was not forthcoming.
Much like with the Simple Option offense however, there's always a little bit of bad sprinkled in with the good.
Prior to this weekend, many Tech fans had visions of top in-state studs like big Monroe HS DE Stephon Tuitt, who was making an official visit, and Tucker LB James Vaughters, who may soon be decommitting from Stanford, dancing in their heads. What they got instead were two very different names: Demontevious Smith and Corey Dennis.
Who?
Smith, arguably the "lesser" of the tandem from Monroe, is a high school QB rated as 2-stars(5.4) by Rivals and who was so lightly regarded as to be completely unranked and unrated by Scout. It is believed that he will be used as a defensive back in college, making him only the latest high school quarterback Tech has recruited specifically to play a different position-- this since Johnson is seemingly unable to compete for players skilled in those positions to begin with.
Always looking for a way to spin the situation however, CPJ Kool-Aid slurpers have clutched to the surprising offer Smith received from BCS bowl punching bag Virginia Tech as evidence of his worth. Of course the bulk of Smith's offer sheet tells a more modest and realistic story, with the involvement of teams such as Air Force, Navy, Buffalo, the Sun Belt's ULM, and FCS schools Illinois St, Harvard, and Georgia Southern. In wrenching Smith away from the Hokies, Coach Johnson apparently filled his head with visions of surpassing Neon Deion himself in playing cornerback, quarterback, A-back, and wide receiver at the same time. But surely Johnson would never lie to a recruit, would he?
Some have also argued that the pursuit of the lowly-regarded Smith might be a ploy to sway his teammate Tuitt, which is the type of strategem many Tech fans have long deplored as unethical and an "SEC practice." It will be interesting to see the reaction in the unlikely case that Tuitt "suddenly" commits to Tech. My guess is there won't be a cascade of threads and posts devoted to calling out Coach Johnson on his lack of ethics.
The third commit of the day, Troy, AL's Corey Dennis, is readily admitted by the Georgia Tech Rivals site as being a "sleeper athlete," and even the toadies have foraged scant material for sugarcoating. Another high school QB who will likely man a different position at Tech, Dennis was unranked and unrated by either major service and otherwise recruited only by his local Sun Belt affiliate Troy and fellow mid-major UAB. He is arguably the biggest reach yet in an class flush with "under the radar" prospects.
The worst of it is that, due to attrition, Tech appears hell-bent on signing 25 players this year! This trio puts them at 21, and makes you wonder what manner of FCS underbrush Coach Johnson will be unearthing in the coming weeks.
We all appreciate your player evaluations. When you're done here, can you call Thomas Dmitroff and help out the Falcons too?
ReplyDeleteI don't claim to be an expert on player evaluations. In fact I am far from it. That is why I cite the evaluations of professionals on recruiting sites and of the 60+ other BCS programs which did not see fit to offer these players scholarships(with the exception of the bone tossed Mr. Demontavious by VT). Are you saying it's a good thing that we're going head to head against service academies, Illinois St, and Ga Southern for recruits?
ReplyDeleteOf course there will always be fellows like yourself, Hiveredtech, etc who will obtain film on these players and make (completely unbiased) "expert" evaluations on how "blazing fast" they are and how much "heart and determination" and "dominance" they show on the field(against other crappy high school players), and then have a big circle jerk about it with all the other slurpers on Stingtalk, The HIVe, etc.
Continue to live in your fantasyland. The one where Coach Johnson uses the magical tingling in his squishy bosom to locate all the Diamonds in the Rough that no one else can possibly detect. I will live in reality, and the reality is that this is not a program on an upward trajectory.
I'm sure you'll be disappointed to hear we just got Tuitt.
ReplyDelete